The Evolution of Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education

Cover of The Evolution of Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education

Challenges, Risks, and Ethical Considerations

Subject:

Synopsis

Table of contents

(18 chapters)
Abstract

The evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in higher education marks a paradigm shift, driving significant changes in pedagogical approaches and learning methodologies. With the rise of generative AI and artificial general intelligence (AGI), institutions have witnessed a transformative era where traditional content creation and delivery are being redefined. Start-ups like OpenAI and Anthropic have been at the forefront, offering tools like ChatGPT and Claude-3, which reshape natural language processing and forecast a future where AI integrations are seamless and pervasive. This chapter provides a critical overview of the current AI-driven applications enhancing personalized learning, content generation, and remote learning. Tools such as Mainstay, CourseGenie, and AIDES demonstrate AI's capacity to improve student engagement and success rates, while Degreed and Gnowbe showcase the broadening horizons of AI in skills building and microlearning experiences. Furthermore, platforms like Elicit and Research Rabbit exemplify the transformation in research and academic writing, albeit not without raising ethical concerns. In conclusion, AI's permanence in the educational landscape is unquestionable, calling for strategic frameworks that empower educators and students to harness its benefits effectively. The imminent expansion of the AI tool ecosystem necessitates preparedness for substantial shifts in educational practices, where ethical considerations and value-based strategies become paramount. Higher education institutions must align with this technological momentum, ensuring AI's potential is maximized in an ethical, inclusive, and impactful manner.

Abstract

This research delves into the transformative potential of Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), particularly ChatGPT, in enhancing higher education. It aims to explore how these advanced AI tools can be integrated into different educational settings to improve interactive learning experiences and student engagement, addressing the current challenges and opportunities in academic and administrative applications. Adopting a qualitative approach, the research utilizes the case vignette method to simulate realistic scenarios in various academic disciplines. It examines the potential applications and outcomes of AI in higher education, structured around key areas like intelligent tutoring systems, assessment, personalization and student profiling. This study employs the 4Cs framework (Critical Thinking, Creativity, Collaboration and Communication) to evaluate the effectiveness of AI integration in improving educational outcomes. The study reveals that ChatGPT can significantly enhance learning experiences by providing personalized tutoring, efficient assessment, tailored content and predictive insights into student performance. However, challenges such as ensuring content accuracy, ethical concerns and balancing AI with human interaction are also identified. Best practices for effectively integrating ChatGPT in higher education are proposed, emphasizing the complementarity of AI and human elements in education. This research contributes to the growing body of knowledge on AI in education by providing a nuanced understanding of generative AI's potential and challenges in higher education. It offers valuable insights and practical recommendations for educators and institutions, guiding the effective integration of AI technologies to enhance teaching and learning.

Abstract

This chapter presents a novel exploration of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) applications within the context of digital transformation in higher education, specifically focusing on the social sciences. Despite the interest in AI technologies for educational enhancement, there remains a notable gap in the literature: a comprehensive comparison of generative AI tools and their effectiveness in social science education. Addressing this gap, our study serves a dual purpose. Initially, we delineate the potential roles and benefits of generative AI in the pedagogical processes of teaching and learning. Subsequently, we conduct an empirical analysis of five leading generative AI engines to assess their performance and applicability in educational settings. Through this investigation, we aim not only to equip educators with a deeper understanding of the advantages and limitations of current AI technologies but also to inform AI developers about the specific needs of social science educators. The goal is to foster the development of more refined and effective generative AI solutions that can significantly enhance educational outcomes in the digital era.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) in education is a rapidly emerging technology that has revolutionised teaching and learning, administrative tasks and research in higher education. The emergence of AI in higher education has impacted the evolving roles of faculty and students, how data is examined and how results are delivered. In this chapter, the different aspects of the role of AI and the transformative power of AI in both academic and administrative spheres are revealed. The case studies presented and future directions reveal AI's capability in transforming education and preparing for an AI-driven workforce. The personalisation of learning experiences, automation of administrative tasks, enhancement of research and impact on instructional design, all made possible through AI, reveal the possibility of tackling long-standing challenges in education, such as accessibility, engagement and efficiency. In the AI-enhanced future that higher education institutions navigate, it is vital to hold on to the principle that AI should be used as a tool for empowerment, innovation and transformation, ensuring that learning goes through the required progress.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is permeating many facets of our daily lives, appearing in household appliances, cell phones and popular online apps. AI has the capacity to revolutionize teaching and learning processes in higher education institutions. The integration of AI technologies in education can lead to personalized learning experiences, improved educational quality and enhanced learning outcomes. However, the adoption of AI in higher education comes with challenges such as ethical considerations and the need to address equity and inclusion issues to ensure that all students benefit from AI advancements. This chapter considers how AI can be utilized in education, while acknowledging the challenges and finding ways to mitigate them. Useful tools include: Bespoke Learning, Intelligent Tutoring Systems, Grading, Collaborative, Learning Assistance, Research Support and Adaptive Learning. The challenges addressed are: ethical considerations, resistance to change and data security and privacy. In navigating the complexities of integrating AI in higher education, institutions must strike a balance between leveraging the transformative potential of AI technologies and addressing the ethical, social and technical challenges that accompany their implementation. By prioritizing ethical considerations, addressing resistance to change and safeguarding data security and privacy, higher education institutions can harness the benefits of AI to enhance teaching and learning practices, foster innovation and prepare students for success in the digital age.

Abstract

This section outlines a framework for incorporating Artificial Intelligence (AI) and digital transformation (DT) into education, focusing on how they can transform teaching methods, curriculum development, and academic evaluations. It traces the evolution of AI from rule-based systems to learning technologies, highlighting the move toward education and innovative curricula. The framework considers both the benefits of using AI to improve practices and the challenges it brings, such as issues and the potential for creating a digital divide. This balanced perspective is crucial in shaping how DT is adopted in education, promoting a fair educational environment that harnesses the advancements in AI and DT. Aimed at policymakers, administrators, and educators, this section is a road map for navigating the complexities of integrating technology into education, contributing to an adaptable and enriched landscape.

Abstract

Given the existing quality concerns of higher education (HE), particularly in the global South, the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been seen as a panacea to improve the quality of teaching learning in HE. AI Chatbots, like ChatGPT, have created profound resonance across HE systems with both positive and negative impacts. Within HE, expectations and concerns related to the quality of HE in general, and teaching learning in particular, loom. It is yet to be investigated how university teachers use AI chatbots in their teaching inside classrooms and its potential to enhance the quality of teaching learning in HE. This chapter sheds light on these questions based on in-depth qualitative interviews with faculty members from six universities in Pakistan. Using a thematic analysis approach, the findings highlight both positive and negative aspects of ChatGPT when used for teaching in HE. Based on the findings, we developed a four-stage framework highlighting faculty members' response to integrating ChatGPT for transforming teaching learning activities. We explain that transformation of teaching learning with AI requires educators to rethink teaching and learning – navigative response – and assess its integration – evaluative response. In conclusion, we discuss how the adoption of AI chatbots provides educators with authentic assessment but will certainly require skills to properly navigate. We further discuss the findings in literature around the quality of HE making some plausible predictions regarding whether chatbots can serve as a quality enhancement tool, mainly in the global South.

Abstract

This chapter critically explores the transformative role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in higher education, highlighting both the opportunities it presents and the challenges it imposes. Focused on pedagogical enhancement, it details how AI-driven adaptive learning systems, tutors, and curriculum adjustments contribute to personalized education. It further examines AI's efficiency in streamlining administrative tasks, like enrollment and support services, while addressing significant ethical concerns, including data privacy and algorithmic bias. Moreover, the impact of AI on research and development is discussed, showcasing its potential to revolutionize scientific discovery through advanced data analysis. A strategic framework is proposed for stakeholders to effectively navigate AI integration and digital transformation, emphasizing a balanced approach that prioritizes innovation, ethical considerations, and quality in the digital era of higher education.

Abstract

The aim of this chapter is to discuss the key challenges that the academia and the academics of higher education have to face in relation to AI but also to make recommendations on the strategies that the academia can adopt so to optimize the use of AI in an ethical manner. Due to the lack of knowledge in the field of AI, there is limited literature on the field of AI, especially on issues related to academic integrity. For this reason, this chapter suggests several recommendations on how AI can be a foe not an enemy of academia. Those practices include the developing a culture of ethos for the use of AI among the stakeholder of higher education, the use of AI as a personalized tutor, and on grading. However, from a critical perspective, the most important issue of AI is academic integrity. At this case the stakeholders of higher education must take immediate action so to ensure the ethical use of IA in Higher Education. The authors of this chapter suggest making modifications on the way that students are assessed, including having more examinations and online quizzes along with written assignments which will promote critical reflections so to avoid the use of AI in written assignments.

Abstract

The connection between critical thinking and students' reliance on Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been examined in this chapter. While there are many educational advantages to AI technology, it has been demonstrated that a heavy dependence on it may impair autonomous problem-solving and critical thinking skills. The research highlights the necessity of incorporating a critical thinking approach into educational programs to assist students in scrutinizing, analyzing, and assessing AI technologies. For data analysis descriptive and correlational analysis were conducted to test the research hypothesis. Furthermore, by honing their critical thinking skills, students will be able to question data supplied by AI, recognize potential biases, assess the validity of sources, and make defensible conclusions. Additionally, the findings show a positive relationship between using AI and critical thinking toward transformation of innovative learning. This study highlights the importance of critical thinking abilities in navigating an AI-driven society by demonstrating a link between higher critical thinking capabilities and a stronger desire to employ AI technology. It is advised that lawmakers and educational institutions give the integration of critical thinking abilities in curricula top priority considering these findings. Furthermore, future studies should focus on the difficulties in integrating AI into classroom environments and the long-term impacts of a critical thinking approach on AI dependence. This chapter's main contention is that critical thinking is necessary for the ethical use of AI, autonomous reasoning, and independent decision-making.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing higher education, offering transformative opportunities to innovate traditional teaching, learning and administrative practices. AI technologies, including machine learning, natural language processing and data analytics, are driving improvements in the educational experience for both students and educators. One key area where AI is making a significant impact is personalized learning. AI-powered systems analyse students' learning patterns and behaviours to customize educational content and delivery methods, enhancing engagement and learning outcomes by catering to individual needs. AI's potential in higher education extends to predicting student success through analytics, enabling institutions to identify students at risk of falling behind or dropping out. Early intervention allows for targeted support, improving retention rates and overall student success. Addressing student at-risk issues in higher education is crucial, requiring institutions to identify and assist students facing challenges that may hinder their academic progress. Institutions must provide support systems for early intervention, such as academic tutoring, counselling services and mentorship programs, fostering a supportive and inclusive learning environment. AI can play a significant role in addressing student at-risk issues by identifying patterns and indicators of students who may need additional support. By analyzing data, such as student performance, attendance and engagement, AI algorithms can flag at-risk students for targeted interventions.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence presents itself as a revolutionary tool that has the potential to completely change the educational environment by providing alternative teaching methods that meet the varied needs of educators and learners. This chapter examines the associated risks as it explores the significant influence of AI on alternative learning approaches in secondary and higher education. An educational change is underway with the introduction of virtual assistants, new platforms, and virtual reality integration. These developments bring with them a variety of teaching methods that respond to the needs of students in the educational process.

Abstract

Aptly named AI: Powering Sustainable Innovation in Higher Ed delves into the transformative power of Artificial Intelligence (AI) as a catalytic force driving comprehensive disruption in Higher Education (AIEd). We begin with an overview of the foundational role AI plays as an enabling technology, reshaping traditional educational paradigms. Through an exploration of intelligent tutoring systems, personalised learning pathways and adaptive assessment tools, we analyse how AI tailors educational experiences to individual needs, fostering a dynamic and personalised learning environment. This chapter scrutinises the challenges and opportunities posed by AI in bridging educational disparities, facilitating access to quality education and fostering inclusive learning environments. Additionally, it analyses the ethical considerations and societal implications inherent in the proliferation of AI-driven educational technologies, probing the delicate balance between innovation and ethical responsibility. Drawing on case studies and empirical evidence, this chapter examines the nuanced impact of AI on emerging markets, elucidating its potential to revolutionise educational ecosystems in regions with distinct sociocultural dynamics and infrastructural limitations. It explores how AI-powered educational tools and platforms can catalyse educational advancements, empower marginalised communities and drive economic growth in these markets. In conclusion, this chapter offers insights into the future trajectory of AI-driven educational disruption, emphasising the need for collaboration between academia, industry and policymakers to navigate the evolving landscape. We conclude by envisioning a future where AI- driven educational technologies play a pivotal role in reshaping the educational landscape, fostering innovation and empowering learners worldwide.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is widely used in higher education teaching and learning. This trend of AI integration will continue to emerge within the education system. To stay ahead of the curve in the education realm, educators shall involve the usage of AI in teaching activities, assessments, and learning experiences. This book chapter aimed to highlight the challenges faced by higher education while proposing refined solutions to educators in involving the usage of AI tools in their teaching pedagogy. The suggested solutions were drafted from three different perspectives of AI to be integrated into its curriculum, namely the 3As triadic approach. Activities are identified as the essential asset to fostering a collaborative learning environment encouraging students to make use of cocreated AI in activities creation. Meanwhile, assessment preparation requires rigorous restrictions on AI usage to portray higher order thinking skills while abiding by ethical guidelines and legal framework. Academic content is prudent in ensuring latest findings and research are credible while bridging the gap between interactive academic materials with students' learning outcomes. Concurrently, we highlighted several approaches to achieve AI collaborative learning and enhance students' experience.

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has revolutionized teaching and learning methods in higher education, especially in English language teaching and learning. This chapter contributes to the existing knowledge by exploring how AI has developed within the framework of teaching and learning of English, highlighting the challenges, dangers, and moral issues associated with its application. The typical classroom environment has significantly changed because of the integration of AI-powered tools and platforms in English instruction. Chatbots, automated grading systems, and language learning apps driven by AI have streamlined language education, increasing its effectiveness and accessibility. But these benefits accompany a variety of challenges and worries. Ethical concerns about data privacy, algorithmic biases, and the depersonalization of education arise as AI becomes more deeply ingrained in educational methods. Reliance on AI may inadvertently exacerbate educational disparities as long as learners' access to technology and its advantages remain unequal. In addition, significant thought must be given to the ethical ramifications of AI-generated content as well as the possible loss of human connection in language learning settings. This chapter examines these dangers and challenges and makes the case for a well-rounded strategy that maximizes AI's benefits while minimizing any potential downsides. Together, educators and legislators need to create moral guidelines that balance the potential of AI with human-centered learning experiences. To ensure responsible and fair AI integration and promote an inclusive learning environment that prioritizes students' holistic development while exploiting technology breakthroughs, comprehensive assessment of the associated obstacles, risks, and ethical issues is necessary.

Abstract

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GAI) can revolutionize higher education by allowing students to pursue their academics easily and comfortably. When this becomes a celebration for students as they get access to information with a click, it also points out the massive impact it can create on academic ethics and responsibility. Most of the research reveals that the results or information generated by these tools, like ChatGPT, sometimes are more general or even false. Are students aware of issues in using tools that align with the integrity of their work? The role and responsibility of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) is to nurture AI literacy in students so that they can use AI tools appropriately for maximum efficiency and capabilities. This study was conducted to primarily understand students' psychological attitudes and beliefs towards using generative AI tools. Secondly, it examined the ethical and moral values the students could consider when applying generative AI tools. A survey of undergraduate students from HEIs all over Oman was conducted using a Five Point Likert Scale, and the collected survey data was analyzed using descriptive statistics, correlation analysis and thematic analysis for open ended questions. According to the respondents, GAI can bring scientific and technological progress in education but not much likely to change their behaviour and bring intellectual advancement. The study could also discover a high sense of moral and ethical values among the respondents while using GAI in education. This research study could form a base to embark on initiating generative AI governance in HEIs of Oman.

Abstract

The dawn of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in higher education (HE) is not just on the horizon; it's here, promising a transformative leap forward. This shift is not simply about adopting new technologies; it's about redefining educational paradigms to meet specific challenges – from enhancing support and critical thinking to improving outcomes and fostering teamwork. This chapter outlines a comprehensive strategy to integrate AI into HE, spotlighting personalized learning, content generation, and remote learning, among others, as key domains ripe for AI's influence. An effective AI strategy will foster excellence and enable HE institutions to unlock the potential of technology for students and faculty alike. At its core, the proposed AI development strategy targets five critical areas: training, career growth, skill enhancement, learning, and team building. These areas ensure that all HE community members are well-equipped to navigate the AI-enhanced landscape of future jobs and challenges. However, realizing the full benefits of AI transcends the deployment of tools and systems; it requires strategic planning, investment in people, and policy changes. HE must cultivate champions to spearhead this transformation, emphasizing that success is not just measured in output but in the cultivation of socially responsible citizens. To harness AI's full capacity, we must transcend outdated stereotypes and metrics, fostering an educational environment that prepares students for the future. The ultimate goal is not just to integrate AI into HE but to use it as a catalyst for growth, innovation, and a better future for all.

Cover of The Evolution of Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education
DOI
10.1108/9781835494868
Publication date
2024-11-25
Book series
Emerald Studies in Active and Transformative Learning in Higher Education
Editors
Series copyright holder
Emerald Publishing Limited
ISBN
978-1-83549-487-5
eISBN
978-1-83549-486-8