Prelims
A Sociological Examination of the Gift Economy: Envisioning the Future
ISBN: 978-1-80455-118-9, eISBN: 978-1-80455-117-2
Publication date: 13 September 2023
Citation
Katunarić, V. (2023), "Prelims", A Sociological Examination of the Gift Economy: Envisioning the Future, Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. i-xii. https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-80455-117-220231014
Publisher
:Emerald Publishing Limited
Copyright © 2023 Vjeran Katunarić
Half Title Page
A Sociological Examination of the Gift Economy
Title Page
A Sociological Examination of the Gift Economy: Envisioning the Future
by
Vjeran Katunarić
University of Zadar, Croatia
University of Zagreb, Croatia
United Kingdom – North America – Japan – India – Malaysia – China
Copyright Page
Emerald Publishing Limited
Howard House, Wagon Lane, Bingley BD16 1WA, UK
First edition 2023
Copyright © 2023 Vjeran Katunarić.
Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited.
Reprints and permissions service
Contact: www.copyright.com
No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying issued in the UK by The Copyright Licensing Agency and in the USA by The Copyright Clearance Center. Any opinions expressed in the chapters are those of the authors. Whilst Emerald makes every effort to ensure the quality and accuracy of its content, Emerald makes no representation implied or otherwise, as to the chapters’ suitability and application and disclaims any warranties, express or implied, to their use.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
ISBN: 978-1-80455-118-9 (Print)
ISBN: 978-1-80455-117-2 (Online)
ISBN: 978-1-80455-117-2 (Epub)
Dedication Page
Dedicated to the memory of my mother, truly a gift-giver
Contents
Acknowledgments | xi | |
Introduction | 1 | |
Chapter 1 | The Empire Meets the Gift Economy | 5 |
Chapter 2 | Was the Gift Economy a Long Prelude to the Market Economy? | 13 |
The Paramount Ignorance of the Gift Economy | 13 | |
The Third Paradigm? | 18 | |
Chapter 3 | The History and Classifications of the Gift Economy | 29 |
Synonyms | 29 | |
On the Gift Economy in General | 30 | |
Other Classifications of Gifts and the Three Worlds Concept | 31 | |
Chapter 4 | Theoretical Approaches to the Gift Economy | 37 |
Neoliberal Approach: Gift as an Aide to Capitalism | 37 | |
Neo-institutional Approach: Capitalism in Cohabitation with State and Gift | 40 | |
Maussian Anti-utilitarianism: The Ethical-political Prominence of Gift? | 41 | |
The Postcolonial Approach: Imperialism Against Native Knowledge and Practices | 44 | |
The Maternal Economy Approach: From “Forced” to “Free” Gift | 45 | |
The Meaning of Gift in Catholic Conservatism | 46 | |
The Primordial Economy of the Mother Goddess: Giving is a One-sided Relation | 48 | |
A Hermeneutic Approach to Gift | 51 | |
Chapter 5 | Can a Mosaic of Different Economies be Sustainable? | 55 |
Excursus: The Gift Connection | 58 | |
Back to the Future | 64 | |
Back to the Present | 65 | |
Chapter 6 | Some Personal Experiences with Gifts: Banal, Tempting, Fascinating | 67 |
Too Early of a Sunset: The “Grace-Gift”? | 69 | |
Chapter 7 | The Quest for an Alternative Infrastructure of the Gift Economy: Nonlinear Time and Evolution | 73 |
Behemoth’s Ultimatum | 74 | |
Doubts About Linear Evolution | 76 | |
Further Issues Concerning Linear Time | 78 | |
The Quest for Nonlinear Time and the Evolution of the Gift Economy | 79 | |
Time Loop: From Physics to Literature | 80 | |
Chapter 8 | The Persistence of an Inappropriate Economy and Power: The (Too) Long Nineteenth Century | 89 |
Epilogue: The Remake of the Macho Man | 92 | |
Chapter 9 | A Forgotten Economy | 95 |
“The Space is Only for the Righteous” | 96 | |
The “Agreement Economy” | 98 | |
Explaining the Failure of the “Agreement Economy” | 101 | |
The Escape to Consumerism? | 107 | |
“Market Socialism”: Unrealized and Impossible or Just Temporarily Postponed? | 110 | |
Chapter 10 | The Fall into the Abyss or Cargo from Distant Neighbors? | 115 |
Time in Future-oriented Literature | 115 | |
Put in the Dark: Disfiguring the Three Worlds | 120 | |
Out from the Shadow: A Cargo from Hidden Stars? | 121 | |
Breaking Away from the Travesty of the Cargo: Beyond Xenophobia and Xenophilia | 122 | |
A Hypothetical Profile of “Them” | 124 | |
Conclusions | 139 | |
References | 145 | |
Index | 153 |
Acknowledgments
Before writing this book, I touched many times on the topic of the gift economy, but only briefly. The most extensive and most interesting part for a large audience was the focus of my honorary lecture entitled “Toward a post-monetary economy” delivered before the Croatian Sociological Society on the occasion of the “Rudi Supek” award, which was granted to me for outstanding achievements in sociology. Some reactions from the audience, which did not consist solely of sociologists, expressed an expected mix of intrinsic curiosity and amazement. For example, a sociologist interested in ecological alternatives expressed an opinion shared by some alternative communities, which is that the withdrawal of money would not be a good solution because it disturbs an important process in the circulation of matter, that is, our shared bloodlines. Another colleague in educational sciences expressed his skepticism toward my idea that future shops would operate without cashiers and that everybody would be free to take whatever is needed. I responded by asking if he, that colleague, had taken ten kilos of bread or one kilo of bread, that is, as much as he needed for that day. He retorted, surely one kilo and no more. I responded: “You see, then, that such an idea is not utopian and is possible to be applied at least in one case; and probably there are many more cases like that.” Of course, I would not describe this proposed idea as realistic in the sense that most people would choose to do the same, that is, to share instead of grabbing for all of the food that they can when given such a rare opportunity.
Now, fast forward to instances of more serious discussion about the ideas and practices of the gift economy that I had with other people in my academic and professional surroundings and for which I am sincerely grateful. First among equals is Katy Mathers, a sociologist at Emerald, who showed an exemplary understanding of what I submitted as a proposal for the book. Very soon a positive anonymous review ensued, with some interesting questions as to how I intended to make an original contribution to a topic which has been covered so many times before. I was immediately ready to take up the challenge.
Soon thereafter the editorial team at Emerald was formed, headed by Brindha Thirunavukkarasu, who regularly followed the development of my manuscript.
Among other interlocutors who seriously contributed to the expansion of my knowledge of the topic and provided me with important references, for which I am very grateful, are Rade Kalanj (an enthusiastic Maussian and scholar of anti-utilitarian economic philosophy), and Dragan Lalović (who introduced me to some important but virtually unknown and apocryphal authors and texts dedicated to the former Yugoslav self-managing economy, especially its variety called the “agreement economy”; many thanks, indeed!).
For Alexandra Ålund and Carl Ulrik Schierup of the Swedish sociological community, my manuscript was another occasion to prolong our old debates about how to evaluate the ex-Yugoslav political economy in the context of the history of advanced social movements striving for social and economic justice and for transcending traditional social and ethnic boundaries.
Last, but not least – quite on the contrary – are two persons for whom the German proverb “Der Zucker kommt zuletzt” (“The sugar comes at the end”) is singularly appropriate. One is John Jacobs, my proverbial and unmatched editor and proofreader, who sometimes understands better what I meant than I do. The other person is Blanka Katunarić, who understands virtually everything, a non-sociologist who explained why sociologists are so unpopular among other professions and broader audiences. It is because, as she says, we are the bearers of bad news rather than good news about the outlook of contemporary society. I hope that in this book I have succeeded in moving on a little bit from a such predicament or at least in reducing the magnitude of the bad news as well as in trying out some good news as regards our common future on this planet. The prospect of a global shaping of the gift economy is one such piece of good news.
- Prelims
- Introduction
- Chapter 1: The Empire Meets the Gift Economy
- Chapter 2: Was the Gift Economy a Long Prelude to the Market Economy?
- Chapter 3: The History and Classifications of the Gift Economy
- Chapter 4: Theoretical Approaches to the Gift Economy
- Chapter 5: Can a Mosaic of Different Economies be Sustainable?
- Chapter 6: Some Personal Experiences with Gifts: Banal, Tempting, Fascinating
- Chapter 7: The Quest for an Alternative Infrastructure of the Gift Economy: Nonlinear Time and Evolution
- Chapter 8: The Persistence of an Inappropriate Economy and Power: The (Too) Long Nineteenth Century
- Chapter 9: A Forgotten Economy
- Chapter 10: The Fall into the Abyss or Cargo from Distant Neighbors?
- Conclusions
- References
- Index