Engineering compliance and worker resistance in UK further education: The creation of the Stepford lecturer

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to explore control and resistance in the UK further education (FE) sector by examining senior college managers’ attempts to engineer culture change and analysing lecturers’ resistance to such measures.

Design/methodology/approach

Data were derived from interviews with managers and lecturers in two English FE colleges and the analysis of college documents. Interview data were analysed thematically using NVIVO software.

Findings

It was found that college managers sought to build consent to change among lecturers based on values derived from “business‐like” views. Culture change initiatives were framed within the language of empowerment but lecturers’ experiences of change led them to feel disempowered and cynical as managers imposed their view of what lecturers should be doing and how they should behave. This attempt to gain control of the lecturers’ labour process invoked the “Stepford” lecturer metaphor used in the paper. Paradoxically, as managers sought to create lecturers who were less resistant to change, individualised resistance intensified as managers’ attempts to win hearts and minds conspicuously failed.

Research limitations/implications

The paper draws on data from two case study colleges and this limits the generalisability of its findings.

Practical implications

The paper provides a critical perspective on the received wisdom of investing in stylised change programmes that promise to win staff over to change but which may alienate those they purport to empower and ultimately lead to degenerative workplace relations.

Originality/value

The paper offers new insights into culture change from the juxtaposed, polarised views of senior managers and lecturers, while highlighting the negative consequences of imposing change initiatives from above.

Citation

Mather, K., Worrall, L. and Mather, G. (2012), "Engineering compliance and worker resistance in UK further education: The creation of the Stepford lecturer", Employee Relations, Vol. 34 No. 5, pp. 534-554. https://doi.org/10.1108/01425451211248541