Paul D. Cousins, Benn Lawson, Kenneth J. Petersen and Brian Fugate
Sustainable supply chain management has become an increasingly important driver of business performance. Understanding the contingent nature of how performance is improved in this…
Abstract
Purpose
Sustainable supply chain management has become an increasingly important driver of business performance. Understanding the contingent nature of how performance is improved in this context is therefore a critical task for management. The purpose of this paper is to explore the moderating effects of two practices unique to sustainable supply chain – ecocentricity and supply chain traceability – on a firm’s environmental and operating cost performance.
Design/methodology/approach
Survey data were collected from 248 UK manufacturing firms and analyzed using moderated hierarchical regression.
Findings
The results suggest that green supply chain management (GSCM) practices are associated with improvements in both environmental and cost-based performance. Further, higher levels of ecocentricity and supply chain traceability are associated with stronger relationships between GSCM practices and cost performance. Contrary to expectations, high levels of supply chain traceability were found to negatively moderate the relationship between GSCM practices and environmental performance.
Research limitations/implications
The research design was survey-based and cross-sectional. Future studies would benefit from longitudinal research designs that capture the effects of GSCM practices on performance over an extended period. The survey data is also perceptual; using secondary data to capture environmental performance outcomes, for example, would be another opportunity for future research.
Practical implications
The authors provide additional support to findings that GSCM practices benefit both environmental and cost performance dimensions. In this context, the authors show that investments by firms in working with a broader set of eco-system partners (ecocentricity) and building supply chain traceability and leads to improved environmental sustainability outcomes. The authors encourage managers to carefully consider how they conceptualize and monitor their supply chains.
Originality/value
This paper offers several contributions to the research in this area. First, the authors develop and validate a measurement scale for ecocentricity and supply chain traceability. Second, the authors show how these two variables – unique to sustainable supply chains – can positively influence firm and environmental performance.
Details
Keywords
Paul D. Cousins, Benn Lawson and Brian Squire
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the different patterns of purchasing function configuration, and the relationship between such patterns and organisational performance.
Abstract
Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the different patterns of purchasing function configuration, and the relationship between such patterns and organisational performance.
Design/methodology/approach
Despite considerable attention, there is little evidence showing the current situation toward the development of purchasing functions within organisations. Through quantitative data collected from 151 UK purchasing executives, cluster analysis is used to uncover and characterize four purchasing function configurations.
Findings
Four configurations, termed strategic, capable, celebrity, and undeveloped, were identified according to the characteristics they possess. Significant differences in supplier‐ and organisational‐related performance outcomes were found across these four purchasing function configurations. Purchasing skills were also shown to be a precondition for purchasing to exert influence within the organisation.
Research limitations/implications
A cross‐sectional survey provides limited longitudinal insight into the evolution of purchasing functions. Future research could examine how firms move between purchasing configurations. This study does, however, improve understanding of the different types of purchasing functions, their performance outcomes, and makes recommendations for potential strategies to be adopted for purchasing function improvement.
Practical implications
The findings are useful for practitioners seeking to improve the performance and standing of the purchasing function through identification of the characteristics and potential limitations faced at each phase.
Originality/value
This paper is one of few studies to provide an empirical test of purchasing function configuration, and the implications for organisational performance.
Details
Keywords
Paul D. Cousins, Benn Lawson and Brian Squire
To introduce the special issue focusing on the question: is supply chain management (SCM) an emerging academic discipline?
Abstract
Purpose
To introduce the special issue focusing on the question: is supply chain management (SCM) an emerging academic discipline?
Design/methodology/approach
A brief discussion of the papers in the special issue.
Findings
Outlines how the papers stimulate debate on the nature and development of SCM and indicates that there is an intense research effort being conducted around the world in this field.
Originality/value
Provides a summary of the perspectives considered within the issue.
Details
Keywords
Paul D. Cousins, Benn Lawson and Brian Squire
Close links between buyers and suppliers are increasingly cited as a critical differentiator of high and low performers in global supply chains. While the application of…
Abstract
Purpose
Close links between buyers and suppliers are increasingly cited as a critical differentiator of high and low performers in global supply chains. While the application of performance measures to manage supplier relationships has been well‐identified and encouraged in the literature, comparatively little research exists on the inter‐organizational socialization mechanisms that underlie the flow of learning and information within supply chains. The authors aim to develop a model positing that socialization mechanisms play an important role in mediating the relationship between supplier performance measures and performance outcomes.
Design/methodology/approach
A structural equation model, using a sample of 142 manufacturing and service firms based in the UK, tests this hypothesised model.
Findings
The theoretical framework was supported, with results indicating that socialization mechanisms fully mediate the effects of supplier performance measures (communication and operational‐based) on firm performance.
Practical implications
This study provides additional insights for purchasing managers seeking to improve the management of their strategic supplier relationships. The authors find that monitoring supplier performance is not of itself sufficient, rather, it is the process of socializing the buyer and supplier that is critical to success.
Originality/value
As far as the authors are aware, no previous supply chain research has examined how supplier performance measurement systems, socialization mechanisms, and firm performance are related. The paper makes a significant contribution to this literature embedding an established theoretical construct (socialization) into the supply chain literature.
Details
Keywords
Paul D. Cousins and Michael J. Crone
This paper seeks to examine the link between the academic debates on obligation contracting and its successful implementation as a mode of governance. The literature reports that…
Abstract
This paper seeks to examine the link between the academic debates on obligation contracting and its successful implementation as a mode of governance. The literature reports that firms are increasingly entering into long‐term, high dependency exchanges as a result of: increased demand for quality goods, demand for variability of goods, demand for constant innovation, severe price competition and increasing technology costs. These changes are forcing firms to enter into complex relationships with other firms in order to remain competitive. Examples of such relationships are: relational contracting, network organisations, strategic alliances and horizontal co‐operation. The increase in number and complexity of these exchanges in an environment characterised by uncertainty has led to the increased interest in the use of obligation contracting. Furthermore, this interest has been reinforced by the changing nature of products being exchanged. More knowledge‐based products and information‐based modes of production necessitate the sharing of strategically sensitive data. Hence the rise of importance of obligation contracting is not only due to the increased number of complex exchanges in uncertain environments, but also the very nature of the goods being exchanged.
Details
Keywords
Abstract
Details
Keywords
Anthony Birts and Paul D. Cousins
The concept of purchasing partnerships is designed to eradicate theadversarial nature of the purchasing process with its resulting costsand inefficiencies, and to replace it with…
Abstract
The concept of purchasing partnerships is designed to eradicate the adversarial nature of the purchasing process with its resulting costs and inefficiencies, and to replace it with a process that is based on a relationship where short‐term advantage gives way to long‐term objectives, in a manner that provides maximum long‐term benefits to both organizations. In the past the main focus in terms of the players involved in purchasing partnerships has been, not unnaturally, on the purchasing/sales and production/ manufacturing relationships within a manufacturing context. Looks at how the partnering philosophy within manufacturing can be strengthened through the involvement of other departments and how technology can lead to partnering advantage.
Details
Keywords
Paul D. Cousins, Richard C. Lamming and Frances Bowen
This paper extends previous literature on the greening of supply chains by giving explicit consideration to two main areas – the role of risk, and the motives for undertaking…
Abstract
This paper extends previous literature on the greening of supply chains by giving explicit consideration to two main areas – the role of risk, and the motives for undertaking different sorts of environment‐related supplier initiatives. A model is presented which describes the extent and type of environment‐related supplier initiatives that may be undertaken by firms as a result of the interaction of the perceived losses to the firm associated with inaction, and the actual level of strategic purchasing in the firm.
Details
Keywords
Aims to prove that a firm's perception of the strategic nature of supply depends on how it defines its competitive advantage within the marketplace.
Abstract
Purpose
Aims to prove that a firm's perception of the strategic nature of supply depends on how it defines its competitive advantage within the marketplace.
Design/methodology/approach
Data were collected using a random stratified cross‐sectional design from 142 large manufacturing firms in the UK. Structural equation modelling (SEM) was employed to test the hypothesised model.
Findings
Firms defining their competitive advantage as being cost‐focused will generally consider supply as playing merely a cost‐reduction role, i.e. passive and supportive, whereas firms viewing their competitive advantage as being differentiated will see supply as strategic, i.e. as a distinctive capability.
Research limitations/implications
This study's single country setting could limit the generalizability of the findings. Replication of the model would require contrasting empirical contexts. Longitudinal as opposed to cross‐sectional data are needed for studying causations. Also future studies should take a multiple‐source as opposed to a single‐source data collection approach. Finally, more empirical research is needed, specifically grounded in the established strategy literature.
Practical implications
The model presented allows managers to understand what strategies to follow and which relationship modes to adopt. This study has a number of implications for strategy makers at the level of the firm and within supply.
Originality/value
Supply management has so far focused on the wrong question. Instead of “why isn't purchasing strategic?”, it should be “what are the firm's strategic goals and priorities?” This refocusing allows exploration of the linkage between the firm's competitive positioning and priorities and that of supply.
Details
Keywords
Brian Squire, Paul D. Cousins, Benn Lawson and Steve Brown
The purpose of this paper is to examine the relationships between supplier capabilities, supply chain collaboration and buyer responsiveness.
Abstract
Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to examine the relationships between supplier capabilities, supply chain collaboration and buyer responsiveness.
Design/methodology/approach
The sample is drawn from UK manufacturing firms across eight industry sectors. Data are analysed using a three‐step hierarchical regression model to investigate main, interaction and quadratic effects.
Findings
The results indicate that suppliers' capabilities (flexibility, responsiveness and modularity) directly impact buyer responsiveness but that the level of buyer‐supplier collaboration moderates this relationship. Furthermore, the results show a curvilinear relationship directly between collaboration and buyer responsiveness, whereby there is an optimal point beyond which returns on the relationship decline.
Research limitations/implications
The method adopted is a cross‐sectional design and therefore cannot imply causality. Nonetheless, the findings suggest a number of implications. The paper identifies empirical evidence for the extended resource‐based view (ERBV) of the firm and therefore has implications for the unit of analysis of future studies investigating competitive advantage. Contrary to popular wisdom, the findings also suggest a curvilinear relationship between supply chain collaboration and performance.
Originality/value
The paper provides novel insights into the impact of supplier capabilities on buyer responsiveness. Furthermore, the paper provides empirical evidence for the rationale of the ERBV within the context of operations management.