Realist Synthesis: An Innovative Approach to Literature Review for Complex Management Phenomena

Abstract

Common literature review methods such as systematic review and narrative review are poorly suited to the investigation of complex management phenomena. Systematic reviews are highly driven by protocol and procedure, and are oft-criticized as reductive and poorly equipped to examine the interaction between phenomena and context, nonlinear processes, and empirical outcomes that are less predictable. Narrative reviews, on the other hand, are pluralistic and iterative and thus better suited to descriptions of the complex and unpredictable; however, they tend to lack methodological transparency, trustworthiness, and pragmatism in application. The “realist synthesis” approach to literature review can be seen as the middle-ground between these two common methods, offering both methodological rigor alongside flexibility and nuance. Realist synthesis takes an explanatory frame, with a focus on unearthing the theorized causal mechanisms at play beneath a phenomenon of interest.

Citation

Pittman, E. (2023), "Realist Synthesis: An Innovative Approach to Literature Review for Complex Management Phenomena", Rana, S., Singh, J. and Kathuria, S. (Ed.) Advancing Methodologies of Conducting Literature Review in Management Domain (Review of Management Literature, Vol. 2), Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. 137-159. https://doi.org/10.1108/S2754-586520230000002008