Exploring legitimacy in major public procurement projects

Abstract

In the UK, major IT public procurement projects regularly fail at significant cost to the taxpayer. The prevalence of these failures presents scholars with a challenge; to both understand their genesis and to facilitate learning and prevention. Functional approaches have revealed numerous determinants of failure ranging from procurement specifications to risk escalation, but true and definitive causes remain elusive. However, since failure is not itself an absolute truth, but rather a concept which is reached when support is withdrawn, the survival of a project depends on there being sufficient belief in its legitimacy. We use critical hermeneutic methods and the conceptual lens of legitimacy to reveal powerful legitimating influences that enable and constrain action, but which are not analysed in the retrospective government inquiries that determine lessons learned.

Citation

Russell, C. and Meehan, J. (2014), "Exploring legitimacy in major public procurement projects", Journal of Public Procurement, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 495-537. https://doi.org/10.1108/JOPP-14-04-2014-B003