Case studies

The case is designed to exemplify the following microeconomics concepts:

▪ factors affecting demand and supply;

▪ movement along the demand and supply curves;

▪ shifts in the demand and supply curves;

▪ price elasticity of demand and supply in the short run;

▪ the cross-price elasticity of demand;

▪ regulated markets; and

▪ government import policies.

Dr Sania Rizvi, an agricultural economist and head of the task force committee on rising food prices, was heading the meeting, focusing on the unprecedented increase in food items generally, mainly the trek in tomato prices. Sania, who had ten years of experience in food supply chain dynamics and market analysis, adopted a thorough approach by considering all the elements influencing tomato prices. This included analyzing issues related to production at the farm level, logistical difficulties, market demand and import policies. The year 2022 brought with it exceptional circumstances of massive monsoon floods, affecting the supply and demand factors in the tomato market. This led to sharp hikes in prices, actual and artificial supply shortages and changes in consumer demand because of expectations of future supply shortages. The massive floods during the monsoon season destroyed standing tomato crops and damaged transport infrastructure, creating a supply shortage. Surviving tomato crops were hoarded by profiteers in hopes of driving prices higher. The Government of Pakistan relaxed restrictions and taxes on tomato imports from Iran and Afghanistan to ease the situation. Moreover, the lack of temperature-controlled storage environments for perishable products, such as tomatoes, presented a significant challenge for the tomato supply chain, particularly in times of crisis, such as the one witnessed in 2022 in Pakistan. Sania’s report was anticipated to play a crucial role in formulating initiatives to alleviate the burden on consumers and establish long-term stability in the market.

Undergraduate and graduate-level programs.

This case is designed for undergraduate and postgraduate courses in a management program focusing on microeconomics. In particular, the theme covered is supply and demand and elasticity analysis. It can also be used in agricultural economics, public policy, supply chain management, and executive training to familiarize participants with these concepts.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 10: Public Sector Management.

After working through the case and the assignment questions, students will be able to:

▪ Examine Ecuador’s business environment where coffee shops and similar companies operate.

▪ Evaluate the marketing challenges for an enterprise, particularly for a café business operating in Ecuador.

▪ Explain the marketing strategy for a café company to attract a variety of new consumer segments domestically and abroad.

▪ Discuss relevant international market entry strategies given the specificities of the environment in which a company operates.

▪ Describe the advantage of contemporary marketing tools in sustainable market expansion of a café business.

Richard Peet and Soledad Hanna turned their coffee shop business, Sweet & Coffee, into a flagship brand in Ecuador. Their coffee shops successfully promoted the culture of consuming coffee and sweets throughout Ecuador and grew exponentially to 129 stores. However, Sweet & Coffee faced significant challenges entering new states in Ecuador, with considerable investment in central kitchens and logistics. Despite the challenges, Peet wanted to continue opening new Sweet & Coffee stores across Ecuador. However, owing to Ecuador’s fast-changing and unpredictable external environment, Peet needed to make new adjustments to its marketing strategy to reposition Sweet & Coffee for a bright future. International market expansion was an option.

This case is helpful for advanced undergraduate or graduate courses in marketing and strategy.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 8: Marketing.

The case study aims to achieve the following learning objectives post discussion by the students: evaluate Social Entrepreneurship Quotient of Anish Malpani, founder of WITHOUT; understand Sustainable Development Goals to which the start-up aims to contribute; apply the framework of SWOT analysis to the social start-up; and analyze triple bottom line and triple top line concepts to identify approach of WITHOUT.

Malpani’s eco-conscious start-up named “Ashaya Recyclers Pvt. Ltd.” is the first of its kind in the world, selling sunglasses made from recycled postconsumer metalized multi-layered plastic packaging (MLP) under the brand name WITHOUT. MLP generally ends up in landfills. It is a low-value, high-volume composite waste that is considered economically and technically “impossible” to recycle. The founder wanted to do something good out of the recycled stuff instead making money. Will Ashaya’s early breakthrough and now patented technology be able to bring significant change in the waste management system in India?

This case study is suitable for undergraduate BBA and postgraduate MBA courses.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 4: Environmental Management.

Students will learn to:

1. Assess the hiring challenges of HR managers in emerging markets.

2. Illustrate the application of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools in the hiring process of new ventures.

3. Evaluate the effectiveness and challenges of technology-based hiring.

The case study centres on Hamada Tea Co. Ltd., exploring its hiring challenges in emerging markets. The protagonist, Hema, the company’s executive director, is grappling with whether to invest in GenAI-based hiring tools or continue with the manual scouting process. The case highlights her journey in recruiting a retail sales executive, providing a detailed look into the hiring difficulties unique to new ventures. Designed for students interested in understanding recruitment processes, this case aims to teach the complexities of hiring in new ventures with resource constraints. Through this case, students can examine how GenAI can potentially overcome these challenges and enhance the effectiveness of hiring processes.

This case can be used for undergraduate and postgraduate students to teach the hiring process and its challenges. It is suited for courses that cover introduction to human resource management, digital transformation in HR, entrepreneurship, talent management practices and GenAI in recruitment.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 6: Human Resource Management.

After completion of the case study, students will be able to understand various capital raising instruments and their impact on different stakeholders; analyse the financials of a company to select a fitting instrument; and communicate the company’s decision effectively, paying attention to language and style.

This case study describes the funding choices available to Tata Motors Limited (TML), a major global automobile manufacturer based in India. Owing to a very high debt-to-equity ratio and very low debt service coverage ratio, the company urgently requires a fresh inflow of funds to bring its debt levels down and sustain growth. This financial state does not benefit the company in the short or the long run. TML has various options: Rights Issue, Qualified Institutional Placement, Preferential Allotment, Global Depository Shares and Follow-on Public Offering. Each mode has implications for individual stakeholders like the management, promoters, institutions with significant and minor stakes, and retail investors. The dilemma before TML is to choose the best capital-raising mode that suits the current requirements. This case study requires participants to choose an equity-raising mode that satisfies the stakeholders and communicate their decision tactfully to the general public.

This case study is suitable for participants in a regular or executive MBA programme. It is designed to introduce the concepts of capital raising, the different instruments available for capital raising and the fundamentals of financial communication. This case study can be used in MBA courses like corporate finance, financial markets and business communication.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS1: Accounting and Finance.

1. Understand the impact of macroeconomic factors on investment portfolios:Students will learn how macroeconomic conditions, such as changes in policy rates by central banks, influence investment decisions and portfolio performance. They will analyze how these factors can lead to significant financial challenges for managed funds.2. Develop strategic financial decision-making skills:Through examining the case, students will practice making strategic financial decisions under uncertain and volatile market conditions. They will explore various options for managing an underperforming investment fund and the potential outcomes of these choices.3. Evaluate risk management techniques:The case provides a platform for students to understand different risk management strategies, including the trade-offs between holding long-term bonds versus reinvesting in short-term securities. They will assess the risks and benefits of these strategies and how they impact fund stability and performance.4. Enhance skills in portfolio management:Students will gain practical experience in portfolio management by examining the fund’s investment decisions, performance metrics and the process of presenting and defending investment proposals. This will involve analyzing the financial and strategic implications of different asset allocations.5. Apply theoretical concepts to real-world scenarios:The case encourages students to apply theoretical concepts such as yield to maturity (YTM) calculation, discounted cash flow analysis, capital asset pricing models and benchmarking against indices to real-world scenarios. This helps bridge the gap between academic principles and practical application in finance.

The case study centered on the Sukkur IBA University in Pakistan, highlighting the challenges faced by its student-managed fund (SMF). From November 2015 to January 2023, the case study offers a comprehensive examination of the fund’s activities in the financial services and higher education domains. Mr Shankar Talreja, the fund manager, contemplating with significant investment losses because of macroeconomic fluctuations, specifically the rising policy rates by the State Bank of Pakistan. These losses challenge the sustainability of the SMF, which serves as a practical learning platform for students. The primary dilemma revolves around whether to continue operating the fund amid consistent losses or to dissolve it, redirecting resources to other educational programs. This case focuses on financial decision-making, risk management and investment strategies, tailored for academic settings.

This case study is intended for use in graduate- and undergraduate-level courses on corporate strategy, investment management and finance. It is appropriate for graduate students who are looking to apply these concepts more deeply as well as undergraduate students who have a strong foundation in finance due to the complexity of the financial concepts involved, such as risk management, portfolio strategy and macroeconomic impacts.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS1: Accounting and Finance.

This case study aims to familiarize the participants with the functioning of the herbal tea industry in an emerging economy like India; understand core concepts, key terminologies and the business relevance of different types of business forecasting; and execute time series forecasting models using MS Excel and interpreting the results.

This case study unveils an important operational concern faced by Deepshika Das, the production manager at Sri Sai Tea Trading Company located at Cuttack in Odisha, India, about future sales projections. The company was gaining popularity for a unique herbal tea called “Chaa Lemon Tea.” However, the company had been experiencing frequent overstocking and understocking due to inappropriate qualitative forecasting. This case study underscores the importance of the concepts associated with quantitative forecasting. It demonstrates the analysis of time series data, building forecasting models and their interpretations using MS Excel.

This case study can be used as a systematic learning tool for postgraduate business school students and master’s level industrial engineering students. This case study can be discussed in courses such as operations and supply chain management, business statistics and quantitative decision-making.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 9: Operations and Logistics.

The learning outcomes are as follows: first, to understand the significance of Agri-tech solutions in the future of agriculture. (Case Question 1) – evaluate the role of Agri-tech firms in promoting sustainable agricultural practices and enhancing productivity. (Case Question 1); second, to analyze the competitive landscape of the agriculture sector in Sindh. (Case Question 2) – assess how the competitive landscape influences Kissan Madadgar’s market entry strategy. (Case Question 2); third, to analyze and evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of Kissan Madadgar’s existing business model and product range in the context of entering a new market. (Case Question 3); fourth to identify key challenges facing the agriculture sector in Sindh. (Case Question 4) – identify potential opportunities in the evolving agriculture market. (Case Question 4) and assess the impact of challenges and opportunities on Kissan Madadgar’s business strategies. (Case Question 4); and fifth, to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of different market entry strategies (online platform only, joint venture with international bodies, opening physical shops, developing a model farm, geographical mapping). (Case Question 5) – analyze the strategic fit of these options with Kissan Madadgar’s objectives and capabilities. (Case Question 5); formulate recommendations based on the best market entry strategy for Sindh. (Case Question 5).

In April 2023, Seema, the head of marketing at Kissan Madadgar, journeyed through the lush rice fields of Sindh, contemplating the province’s distinct agricultural landscape. Despite Kissan Madadgar’s success in Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Gilgit Baltistan, entering Sindh presented a set of unique challenges. The province’s linguistic diversity, with various dialects of Sindhi spoken in key agricultural regions, posed a significant communication barrier. Additionally, farmers in Sindh grappled with limited water access, reliance on expensive solar tube wells and crippling debt due to high-interest loans from traditional lenders. Competing against well-established local agro-tech players, such as BaKhabar Kissan and Farmdar, further complicated the task of gaining trust and building brand recognition. Recognizing these hurdles, Seema partnered with Sukkur IBA University to conduct comprehensive research and develop a tailored entry strategy for the region. Potential entry strategies included maintaining an online-only model, forming joint ventures with international organizations, opening physical shops, establishing a model farm and adopting a cluster-wise entry approach. Each option had distinct advantages and challenges. As Seema found herself at the crossroads of decision-making, the urgency to craft a winning strategy for Kissan Madadgar’s entry into Sindh intensified. She knew that understanding Sindh’s unique market dynamics was crucial, as was assessing Kissan Madadgar’s strengths and weaknesses. Amidst strong local competition, Seema pondered the dilemma: Which entry strategy should Kissan Madadgar adopt to ensure not just a successful entry into Sindh but also sustainable growth and competitive advantage in the long run?

Undergraduate and Graduate (first year only)

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 8: Marketing.

Learning Objective 1: Develop students’ ability to critically assess and probe the challenges of aligning business objectives with compliance to local and international environmental regulations. Students will learn to identify how tensions between regulatory compliance and business goals influence decision-making processes in resource-intensive industries.

Learning Objective 2: Increase problem-solving skills of students by exploring the trade-offs between economic growth and environmental stewardship. They will be able to examine real-world dilemmas, such as community displacement, biodiversity loss, and pollution in mining contexts, and understand how to navigate these complex challenges using insights from Dr Nick’s experiences.

Learning Objective 3: Advance integrative learning, inquiry and interpretive capabilities of students by demonstrating the significance of ESG principles in mining operations focusing on environmental management, community engagement, and ethical governance. Students will learn how to integrate these principles into corporate strategies to achieve a balance between profitability and sustainability.

Learning Objective 4: Equip students with hands-on experience through real business scenarios by addressing dilemmas companies face in the era of climate change and appreciate the role of leadership in driving and implementing sustainable practices. Students will understand how leaders like Dr Nick balance stakeholder interests, ethical standards, and operational efficiency, and how this balance impacts the company’s growth and sustainability objectives.

This case introduces students to the difficulty an environmental manager faces in balancing the interests of the community at large with the company’s goals. Dr Nick Okello, an environmental manager at Base Titanium, is the protagonist of the case. For several years, Dr Nick has overseen the business’s environmental programs at the high-grade mineral sand mine called Kwale Operation, which is situated along Kenya’s coast. The case allows students to explore how Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles are applied in a mining company setting by using this case study. Simple assessments can be applied by students to evaluate ESG and discuss their analysis of it. The mining industry’s intricate relationship between corporate governance, business strategy, and environmental stewardship is exemplified by the Dr Nick case at Base Titanium. It provides a critical analysis of the difficulties businesses confront in attempting to strike a balance between sustainable ethical business practices and economic growth, especially in areas where governance issues are common.

This case is suitable for use in executive education, MBA, senior undergraduate, and other graduate-level business programs in courses such business management, organizational behaviour, environmental sciences, project management, strategic management, operations, finance, corporate governance, leadership, and sustainable development.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS 4: Environmental Management.

The case was an application of a market demand and supply mechanism and its impact on the product’s price and focus on the following objectives:▪ Analyze the vegetable market in India and the challenges faced by the farmers (tomatoes) using demand and supply concepts.▪ Examine the impact of price elasticity on the revenue of the farmers.▪ Assess the challenges faced by the government in controlling prices of vegetables and food inflation.▪ Evaluate diversification strategies in agriculture to mitigate risk.

The market for tomatoes was highly cyclical because of erratic rainfall, and farmers went through a difficult time, especially when the prices fell below the cost of production. They moved out for crops that had stable prices. They expected government support for price stability. Government and policymakers considered price fluctuations a short-term phenomenon that required limited interventions when prices were high. This case was about Dilip, a farmer who was into farming tomatoes on a large scale in Karnataka, India. He was facing a dilemma as to whether he had to continue or move to other crops because of the low price of tomatoes in May 2023 or to diversify into some small but related business. He was worried at the same time, curious to understand the volatility in the prices of tomatoes, government responses, risks and returns associated with the cultivation of this crop and Agri-supply chain. Based on his understanding, he should make decisions to continue or diversify into some other farming or related business.

This case was written for microeconomics and managerial economics of undergraduate and postgraduate students. This case demonstrates the application of the demand and supply mechanism for a perishable product such as tomatoes. Price fluctuations are common in these markets because of various uncontrollable factors such as rain, pests and natural calamities. The case could show the relationship between the firm’s elasticities and revenue. This case also highlights the policy constraints in controlling the prices in the short run. This case could also be used for understanding macroeconomic concepts such as food inflation and its impact on general price inflation. The students or target audience with a background in the functioning of the markets could very well relate to the concepts discussed.

Teaching notes are available for educators only.

CSS: Entrepreneurship (3); Management Science (7).